On the Perils of Travel Writing

Travel Stories: David Farley broke into the New York Times with a story about an eccentric Italian village. When he returned, he feared being chased out by torch-bearing villagers.

After dropping my bags at my apartment, I headed to Pancho’s restaurant for lunch. I was hungry, so I avoided the piazza, knowing I’d run into someone who would either want to hug me or hit me. Instead, I wandered the winding lanes and encountered Romano, the painter whose one-woman fan base had been stalking me back in New York.

“Why you don’t write about me in your article,” he asked. But before I could answer, he said. “I would give you one thousand euros if you wrote about me.” It was yet another first: a bribe, although he laughed so heartily that I took his words as a joke. At least I wanted to. I told Romano that I would have never taken the money anyway. Thinking quickly, I said the editors cut him out due to space issues (when in doubt, blame the editor).

In the next few days, one by one, I ran into locals I hadn’t seen for a few months. Some of them walked by and didn’t say a word; others returned my greeting with a distant “ciao.” I made a point to never walk by Gianni Macchia’s café, but when we did run into each other—at the stone gate—we both just giggled nervously at each other.

The problem went beyond some of the local artists’ anger about not making it into the article. Some were angry that I included their arch-enemies. Others were angry that they were in it but not quoted. I had once loved living in Calcata, a fortress town where dinner parties on the square would often erupt in singing and joint smoking; where you could walk 50 feet and eat at an amazing restaurant; where you could make the intimate square your living room. But now, after the article came out, I felt like a persona non grata for at least half of the place. I hated that I was hated.

But then one day while sitting on the square chatting with one of the few people who still talked to me, my friend Omar, a stranger approached, asking if I spoke English.

“Fluently,” I said. He was holding a newspaper article. My newspaper article. And he wanted to know how to find some of the places mentioned. I gave him directions and he went on his way. Then a couple of days later another person turned up with my article asking the same question. “Is that a good article?” I asked.

“I wouldn’t have come here if I hadn’t seen this in my local paper,” the woman from Houston said. It turned out, the article went out on the Times’ wire service and was picked up by a dozen or so other newspapers. There was even an article about my article in La Stampa, the daily newspaper of Turin. In the coming weeks, I’d see versions of my article in numerous newspapers, including the Seattle Times, the Boston Globe, and the Toronto Star. Interestingly, the South Florida Sun-Sentinel and the Dallas Morning News cut the two paragraphs about the town’s famous relic, the Holy Foreskin; the newspapers in Poland and Mexico, however, did not.

I never came straight out and told anyone I was the author of the article, but if I was sitting on the square with my wife, Jessie, or our friends Elena or Omar, they’d feel it was their duty to volunteer the information. Which, when I thought about it, must have been an interesting surprise: We don’t often get to meet the person who inspires us to alter our itineraries. I soon became a photo magnet for tourists, often being made to pose with them as I awkwardly displayed the article in front of me. Sometimes the jaded villagers would look on from across the square and glare at me as I’d pose for photos with tourists or was asked to autograph copies of my article. A few times someone had told the tourists where I lived (passive aggressive locals, perhaps) and random strangers would just show up at my apartment wanting to meet me.

Another time, my mother-in-law, who was visiting, started chatting with a woman from Portland at the front door of an apartment. When she opened the door a little wider, we could see about a dozen lesbians having a wild wine-fueled party. “We’re biking around Italy,” said the woman, “but then an article about Calcata came out in our local paper and we knew we just had to come here.” Knowing what was about to happen, I steeled myself as my mother-in-law, a proud look on her face, put her arm around me and announced that I was the author of the article. I was suddenly yanked into the raucous party, a plastic cup of vino put in one hand, my article put in the other, and forced to pose in photos with each of the women.

Eventually, when locals saw the amount of tourist traffic the article produced for Calcata’s businesses, the “ciao” ratio began going up. There were still people who acted cold to me, but as Pancho told me one day, that’s almost a rite of passage to being a Calcata resident. “Everyone here has enemies. We’ve all lived on this medieval island for years. We’ve loved and hated and loved each other again. If you’re going to live here, it’s just something you’ll have to accept.”

He was right. As usual, Pancho had a way of putting a convincing and positive spin on just about everything. Not that it lasted very long. 

The next time I ran into Romano, he said a guy who only comes to Calcata on the weekends had requested my presence at his house for dinner that night. “How nice,” I responded, thinking I was feeling some love, finally. “Sure. That would be great.”

“But I must warn you,” Romano added. “He only invites you because he read your article and wants to attack you for it.”

I declined the dinner invitation. Instead, I went somewhere I was welcomed: the Grotta, Pancho’s restaurant.

For the record, I don’t think I ever ruined Calcata, as some people there had feared. If anything, I only ruined it—or at least half of it—for one person: myself.




16 Comments for On the Perils of Travel Writing

Lindsay 07.06.09 | 12:12 PM ET

Oh man…how sad!

Lindsey 07.06.09 | 12:36 PM ET

Living on the edge of danger! Sweet! I can totally relate. Some people love you, others not so much.

elena 07.06.09 | 2:48 PM ET

Very interesting article. next time i go down to Rome area, I will try to stop at Calcatta.

One side note.. when you say “the village is known to Romans and others in the area as the paese di artisti, village of artists, or, more irreverently, “paese di fricchettoni,” village of freaks”...
fricchettoni actually means gays, so i don’t know if i would throw that phrase around. I’m sure the locals use that phrase, but whoever uses it didn’t want to admit what it really meant I think.

besides from that, great article and I will be sure to pick up a copy of your book!!

Frank Bures 07.07.09 | 10:45 AM ET

Actually, it looks like fricchatoni is a straight anglicization of “freak” from English, meaning something like “big freak.”

Frank Bures 07.07.09 | 10:50 AM ET

Sorry: make that Italianization, and make it with and “e.”

RosiC 07.07.09 | 4:43 PM ET

After years of working as a newspaper reporter in the Dallas area, I became a freelance writer.
But only after writing for a half dozen dailies for years, did I discover travel writing was what I wanted to do.
That’s why I loved reading all about how you broke into travel writing, a “closed shop” in journalistic circles. Having traveled extensively, and written on my travels sporadically, I can empathize with what happened to you in Calcatta.
Travel articles abound, but you really have to search several media to be as inspired as your readers were to visit Calcatta.  Personally, I would not visit any locale that promises a return to my familiar life.  Hippies and their attendant penchants for drugs and the like, would actually inspire me to avoud Calcatta. 
But good luck in your sojourns and with your up coming novel, which I intend to read!!

David Farley 07.07.09 | 4:54 PM ET

Thanks RosiC and everyone else who commented. Drugs or no drugs, Calcata is definitely worth a visit. It’s a wonderful, beautiful place. And thanks for saying you’ll read my travel memoir on my time in Calcata. I hope you like it.

Nancy D. Brown 07.07.09 | 5:33 PM ET

Great post. I love the fact that you didn’t feel a need to jump in and tell everyone that you were the travel writer behind the Calcata article. I hope our paths will cross someday; perhaps in Calcata.

Virginia Case 07.08.09 | 8:56 PM ET

Ahhhh, bella Calcata. I have fond memories of that creaky town perched precariously among thousands of hazelnut trees. My inlaws lived there. My favorite dog came from a litter in town and I loved going there to visit the locals back in the 80’s.
One of my companions e-mailed me this article and it was a trip down memory lane. I remember that when I was there, the town was still on the condemned to die a horrible death, though the new residents were not going down without being dragged from their homes, kicking and screaming.
I always remembered feeling like the town might just topple into the deep canyons below, so steep were the slopes. What I don’t remember was the foreskin. How that could have slipped me by….
Thanks for sharing David and remember, those italiani love a good drama and you provided grist for the mill. I am sure it will be a lively summer.
signed, a nostalgic ex-pat.

Jessiev 07.09.09 | 9:14 PM ET

it is always a toss-up for travel writers to truly write of a place (beyond gorgeous beaches, fantastic food, etc.). but no place is perfect. i loved your book and also, calcata. it is the characters of a place that make it memorable!

Luna 07.10.09 | 1:12 AM ET

Great story, Farlito. Next time I’m in Calcata, I’ll be sure and carry your article around with me, as well as a 5x7 headshot of you, and boast that I know the author who put the town on the map.

Todd Zuniga 07.11.09 | 8:28 PM ET

Great piece, really enjoyed reading this. Now to add Calcatta to my itenerary!

Danny Bloom 07.15.09 | 2:24 AM ET

Great picee. I was in Rome in 1971 when Lazlo Toth the Hungarian guy went into the Vatican and smashed the Pieta witt a hammer. he was my room mate at the local youth hostel. he read the bible every day. he eventually thought he was Jesus. Where is he now? Ask me how i met him….funny story. danbloom AT gmail

Danny Bloom 07.15.09 | 2:46 AM ET

notify me of followups

Ben Burns 07.15.09 | 9:17 AM ET

A very nicely written story, Mr. Farley.  Your students at NYU are lucky to have you.  Ben Burns

Michael Shapiro 07.16.09 | 2:33 PM ET

1,000 euros to includes someone in a story - finally a way to pursue our passion and make a living! I’m sure the old gray lady would be fine with that.

On a serious note, when I interviewed Frances Mayes for “A Sense of Place” she mentioned she’d changed the names of some of the villagers mentioned in “Under the Tuscan Sun” and they were so disappointed - they want their real names in there and saw it as their shot at immortality. We always gotta remember how much influence (or perceived power) we wield with our pens. Great piece Farley - can’t wait to read the book.

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.